Insulation
How much loft insulation do you actually need?
Almost every article on this subject gives you one number and leaves. The number is not useless, but it describes a material, not your loft, and the gap between those two things is where most of the wasted money goes.
Where 270mm comes from
The figure you see everywhere is 270mm of mineral wool. It is not a legal minimum for an existing house and it is not a magic depth. It is roughly what you need of that particular material to reach the thermal performance the standards aim at. Change the material and the number changes with it: rigid boards get there in much less depth, loose-fill behaves differently again.
So the question is not really "how many millimetres". It is "does this loft reach the performance, with whatever is actually up there".
The two-minute check
Put your head through the hatch with a torch and a tape measure and look for four things.
Depth against the joists. A ceiling joist is commonly around 100mm deep. If the insulation is level with the top of the joists and no higher, you are at roughly a third of where you want to be — and that is the single most common thing we find.
Whether there is a second layer, and which way it runs. The first layer sits between the joists. The second should run across them, at right angles, covering the timber. Joists conduct heat far better than wool does, so a loft insulated only between the joists leaks heat in stripes along every one of them. Crossing the second layer is what stops that, and it is cheap to do and frequently skipped.
Gaps. Round the hatch, at the eaves, under pipework, where someone has pulled it back to reach a cable and not put it back. Insulation is unforgiving about gaps in a way people underestimate: a small percentage of a ceiling left bare costs a disproportionate share of the benefit.
Whether it is compressed. Mineral wool works because of the air trapped in it. Flatten it under boards or boxes and you have not got thinner insulation, you have got worse insulation per millimetre. If somebody has boarded straight onto the joists over the top of it, the wool underneath is doing a fraction of its job.
When more is not better
Three situations where piling on depth is the wrong answer.
If the loft is already at full depth and properly crossed, another layer buys you very little. Insulation has sharply diminishing returns: the first 100mm does most of the work, and each layer after that does less.
If the eaves are already tight, more wool pushed into them blocks the ventilation path and causes a damp problem that costs more to put right than the heat you saved. The insulation should stop short and let air come in over the top of it.
If you want to use the loft for storage, depth alone makes it unusable — you cannot walk on it and you cannot stand anything on it without crushing it. That is a boarding question, not an insulation question, and the two have to be designed together.
What a survey should tell you
A proper look at a loft takes about half an hour and should end with you knowing: what depth is there now, whether it is crossed, whether the eaves are clear, whether anything is damp, and whether the ceiling below will carry what you want to put up there. If a surveyor gives you a price without going into the loft, they have priced a guess.
Ours are free, and there is no obligation at the end of one. Book a survey or ring the office on 0161 222 8727 and we will tell you honestly if yours does not need doing.
Common questions
How deep should loft insulation be?
Around 270mm of mineral wool is the usual target for a new installation. Other materials reach the same performance at different depths, so the depth matters less than whether the loft as a whole reaches the standard.
Do I need to remove old loft insulation before topping up?
Usually not. If the existing layer is dry, clean and not compressed, a new layer laid across the joists on top of it is the normal approach. Old material that is damp, contaminated or has been crushed is better taken out.
Why does the second layer go across the joists?
Because timber joists conduct heat much better than insulation does. A layer running across the top of them covers that path; insulation only between the joists leaves a heat leak along every joist in the ceiling.